This assignment does not count toward the final grade.

Rubric

Essay 1 Rubric: Adichie Rhetorical Analysis (1)
Essay 1 Rubric: Adichie Rhetorical Analysis (1)
Criteria Ratings
Thesis
Strong Thesis is a statement about the effectiveness of Adichie's argument/strategies and is easily identifiable.
Meeting Expectations The thesis is not clearly laid out in the introduction. The thesis may not be a clear, argumentative thesis that clearly and directly answers the prompt. It may be an announcement instead of a solid, clear, opinionated statement. It may be vague and more of an observation rather than an opinionated statement about the effectiveness of Adichie's strategies.
Not Yet The thesis cannot be identified or is missing. The paper lacks a clear focus because the thesis is unclear and there is no statement regarding the effectiveness of Adichie's rhetorical strategies.
Grammar
Strong 1-2 Proofreading errors (misspelling, missing commas)
Meeting Expectations Grammar errors are distracting but do not interfere with comprehending the essay.
Not Yet The grammar makes the language hard to understand and therefore impacts the content comprehension.
MLA
Strong 0 errors in MLA but perhaps citation formatting is inconsistent
Meeting Expectations 1-2 errors in MLA
Not Yet 3 or more errors in MLA
Organization
Strong The essay's body paragraphs follow logically. Each paragraph discusses one specific strategy (or 2-3 if the strategies relate to one another) and stays on topic and connects to the topic sentences. There are transitions to guide the reader from sentence to sentence and paragraph to paragraph.
Meeting Expectations The essay's body paragraphs follow logically; however, 1-2 paragraphs may have an unclear focus or topic sentence. At times, the student may try to discuss more than 1 unrelated strategy in the same paragraph or the strategy may not be explicitly identified. There are some transitions to guide the reader from sentence to sentence and paragraph to paragraph, but there may be a couple places where there are missing transitions.
Not Yet The essay does not move smoothly through the body paragraphs. Ideas may be repeated in different paragraphs, and paragraphs may not have clear topic sentences which do not identify the strategy from Adichie's Ted Talk. Transitions are missing. It's hard to see how ideas are logically connected.
Use of evidence
Strong The student chooses specific quotes from Adichie's speech that directly illustrate the rhetorical strategies stated in the topic sentences for each body paragraph. The student demonstrates an understanding of how to locate the strategies and label them accurately.The evidence is contextualized and introduced before the quote is used.
Meeting Expectations Most of the chosen quotes accurately identify the student's strategies from the topic sentence, but there are 1-2 paragraphs that have evidence which is not clearly related to the rest of the paragraph or that may inaccurately illustrate the strategy in the topic sentence. 1-2 quotes may not match the strategy in the topic sentence. Also, some evidence may not be contextualized and may be dropped into the paragraph abruptly.
Not Yet The evidence used is hard to connect logically in the paragraphs because it is unclear how the quote illustrates the strategy from the topic sentence. There are other pieces of evidence that would have more accurately identified the strategies throughout the paper. It may be that the majority of the quotes are not contextualized and therefore, it is hard to see the relevance of the evidence used.
Style and Mechanics
Strong No use of second person pronouns, student uses formal, academic voice.
Meeting Expectations Either student uses second person OR student uses informal tone.
Not Yet Use of second person AND informal tone
Analysis
Strong Throughout the paper, the student thoroughly discusses: 1) how the quote illustrates the strategy from the topic sentence 2) why that strategy specifically persuades Adichie's specific, intended audience 3) why the audience would then be convinced of Adichie's overall argument because of the rhetorical strategy used
Meeting Expectations In the paper, the student consistently discusses 2 of the following (or adequately discusses all 3 but not thoroughly): 1) how the quote illustrates the strategy from the topic sentence 2) why that strategy specifically persuades Adichie's specific, intended audience 3) why the audience would then be convinced of Adichie's overall argument because of the rhetorical strategy used
Not Yet In the paper, the student makes an attempt at analysis but only covers 1 or fewer of the following consistently (or varies discussion of 1 of the following throughout): 1) how the quote illustrates the strategy from the topic sentence 2) why that strategy specifically persuades Adichie's specific, intended audience 3) why the audience would then be convinced of Adichie's overall argument because of the rhetorical strategy used